First Work Meeting in Brussels

MINUTES
Work Meeting EURADA, KEN, FEI
Date: July 6, 2011
Time: 15.00 h – 16.30 h
Venue: FEI office

Attendees:
Mr. Christian Saublens, Executive Director EURADA
Mr. Boris Cizelj, Chairman of the Board of Directors, KEN
Mr. Boris Šavle, Network Coordinator, KEN
Mrs. Nadya Gabriel, Managing Directors, FEI

Issues discussed
Summary

Objectives of the Meeting
Partners’ Background
Reason for Action
Steps suggested
Action Plan

 

1. Objectives: Brainstorming on Modeling & Promoting
European System for Strategic Planning Capacity
Assessment & Certification

2. Partners Background:

2.1. The three organizations are involved in activities relevant to policymaking & implementation in the field of Regional Development, Economic Development, Strategic Planning, Growth & Jobs; EU policies & Financial Instruments, EU Enlargement; Conditionality

2.2. The three organizations are acting in the field of Building Human Capital in the fields listed above, Building Capacity for Strategic Management; Consultancy

2.3. The three organizations are utilizing significant experience and expertise in the field listed above both, in – house and also as managing networks of organizations and individual experts. The total number of EURADA’s and KEN Members is about 80 organizations

2.4. The three organizations enjoy remarkable experience working with Regional & Local governments from all Member States, including SEE and Central Europe

2.5. The Partner on the ground. One of the three organizations Formula Europa Institute (the party initiated the meeting) is specializing in research in Territorial Development. The organization is direct participant in projects on the ground. In the framework of these projects FEI has developed (in the Municipality of Stara Zagora, Bulgaria) a Permanent Laboratory for Experiments & Tests which serves as a reliable source for first hand information from the ground, detecting bottlenecks in local governance, building instruments for improvement and testing the instruments in real life. The project was awarded with prize for Best partnership between Local Government and NGO.

In another on-the – ground project (Municipality of Balchik, Bulgaria), FEI registered a local NGO, which participates as a partner in a Local Initiative Group (LAG) funded by Program LEADER+. The Project is developed as a Case Study which is giving access for the policymakers in Brussels to the real process of public management on local level in one of the newest member- states. Bulgaria is an EU member since 2007, with about 10 % EU funds implementation success rate up to date, described as a country, which was not prepared for accession. The two projects mentioned provide FEI, and the European Community with a sound information directly from the ground allowing conclusions to be made about how the proper EU candidate member preparation should look like and how this goal could be achieved.

2.6. The Partner securing the All – Sectors – Actors. EURADA is enjoying long years experience working with all European Regional Development Agencies. These regionally established organizations (in most of the cases publicly owned) have the mission to serve as instruments for building & managing regional partnerships which guarantee that key actors from all sectors are participating in the process of decision –making in
the field of Regional Development. EURADA’s experiences with large number of actors is adding to FEI on -the -ground experience a very large data base which allows the Partners to summarize the conclusions built in individual case studies and get the whole picture.

2.7. The Partner bringing Regional & Local Governments on the table. KEN is a network of 39 organizations, some of them Regional & Local Governments which are directly involved with policy & decision making process and are motivated to promote Knowledge Economy based on Human Capital Building and good practices exchange. Big number of KEN’s network members are basically representing the actors who are the vehicles of Strategic Planning Capacity on regional & local level and as such they are the subjects of reformation (improvement) which is the mission of the soon – to – be developed and implemented System for Strategic Planning Capacity Assessment & Certification

3. Reason for Action. The three organizations want to raise the EU Community attention to some trends in the field of Territorial Development which the Partners consider as important for European citizens economic security and European Economy competitiveness.

3.1. Actors which this message should reach:

 EU Experts working in the field of Economic Development Strategic Planning & Policy – making
 Regional & Local Governments
 EU Institutions involved with EU Regional Policy, EU Cohesion Policy; EU Economy competitiveness, EU enlargement, others
 Universities and training organizations teaching the Art of Territorial Development, Economic development, Public Administration
 Certification companies involved with ISO 9001 – 2008 certification process which is supposed to legitimize the local governments’ actual capacity for strategic management

3.2. Trends which the Partners believe should be noticed:

Trend 1: The Globalization is pushing regions towards strong competition and aggressive territorial investment marketing. In result the Regional & Local Governments are faced with a new mission: From administrative to strategic public management.

Trend 2: Administrative reforms in some EU member – countries (especially in newest members) are not securing optimal capacity for strategic management on Regional & Local level. In result, some Regions are losing speed and instead decreasing are increasing the disparities in economic development

Trend 3: Cohesion Policy can NOT serve as an instrument for decreasing disparities if Optimal Level of Strategic Planning Capacity is missing on regional and local level

Trend 4: Regional & Local Governments which do not perform sufficient in economic development usually do not understand the importance of Strategic Management and are not motivated to invest funds and efforts in improving their Strategic Planning Capacity

Trend 5: Reflections of lack of Strategic Planning Capacity can be traced as:

 Slow and insufficient recovery from global economic crisis
 Lack of investors’ interest
 Slow process of new jobs delivery
 Not balanced urbanization process
 trade space per capita significantly exceeding income level
 speed in increase of number of inhabitants significantly exceeding the speed of building proper infrastructure
 lack of potential for infrastructure rehabilitation on local, regional and national level, considering EU budget as only source for solution
 Lack of integrated town planning concepts
 Brocken streets, buildings falling apart
 Lack of understanding that these issues are solved by proper policies and strategies
 Corruption

Trend 6: Regional & Local Governments which are champions in demonstrating lack of capacity for Strategic Management are usually holders of ISO 9001 – 2008 Certificate which mission is to serve as a proof for a healthy management system – serious confrontation between ISO Certificate public mission and actual results

3.3. Drivers for improvement suggested:

Driver 1: EU Community develops Unified Measures & Standards for Optimal Strategic Planning Capacity mandatory for all European Regional & Local Governments and candidate member – countries

Driver 2: The Unified European Standards for Optimal Strategic Planning Capacity are taken under consideration by European ISO Accreditation Board and ISO 9001 – 2008 Certification Companies when Regional & Local Public Management Systems are assessed & certified. The same logic is eventually applied when ISO Certificate is monitored and renewed

Driver 3: Training Programs for improving Regional & Local Governments Strategic Planning Capacity are developed and implemented

Driver 4: Training programs for ISO Certification Companies’ auditors are developed and offered

Driver 5: European network of Licensed Testing Agencies (serving as an independent third party advising the ISO Certification companies) is developed

4. Steps suggested:

The three organizations sign a Memorandum for Understanding providing the framework for joining forces aimed to apply the solutions suggested
The Memorandum is open for other prospect partners among the actors listed in paragraph 3.1

5. Action Plan

5.1. MoU between the three organizations ratified before July 15, 2011

5.2. Prospect new partners identified & selected, before July 23, 2011

5.3. Concept for building Standards Committees and Invitations for Membership sent to the selected Partners before July 30, 2011

5.4. Planning kick – off meeting with Partners end of September, 2011.

 

Formula Europa Institute
Brussels, July 11, 2011

Disclaimer: Institute for Research, Innovation, Territorial Development and Public Management Formula Europa is organization supporting the EU policy making process. Dealing with this document following principles of the EU should be taken under consideration:
(…) Democracy depends on people being able to take part in public debate. To do this, they must have access to reliable information on European issues and be able to scrutinize the policy process in its various stages.
(…) the Institutions and Member States need to communicate more actively with the general public on European issues.
(…) The Institutions and national authorities must reinforce their efforts to consult better on EU policies. Better consultation complements, and does not replace, decision- making by the Institutions.
(…) The Union is based on the rule of law.